Local Business Data Source Optimization

SQLs from Systematic Data Source Experimentation

Systematic experimentation identified a specific offline marketing database as the most reliable for local business owner contact information.

Book a Call

Case Studies

Local Business: 25 SQLs from Data Optimization

INDUSTRY

B2B SaaS, Local Business

Company Size

SMB to Mid-Market

Target Market

Local business owners seeking technology solutions

Business Model

B2B SaaS for Local Businesses

B2B SaaS Provider Targeting Local Business Market with Technology Solutions

This case study examines a three-month B2B outreach campaign targeting local businesses that generated 25 sales qualified leads from 5,000+ outreach sales targets. The campaign systematically tested three different data sources to identify the most effective approach for local business prospecting.

Finding reliable contact information was identified as the primary blocker for local business outreach success, not messaging or outreach setup. This led to systematic experimentation over three months to optimize lead generation effectiveness.

OBJECTIVE 1

Generate sales qualified leads interested in pricing

OBJECTIVE 2

Test and compare effectiveness of data sources

OBJECTIVE 3

Identify most reliable local business contact method

KEY RESULTS

An Offline Database Emerges as Clear Winner for Local Business Data

Three-month systematic testing identified a specific offline database as the most reliable source with best response rates.

25 SQLs

from 5,000+ outreach attempts

1.7%

no-reply rate achieved

1%

positive reply rate

Winner

Offline Database identified

CHALLENGES

Contact Information Reliability, Not Messaging, Was Primary Blocker

Systematic testing was required to identify the most effective data source for local business owner information.

KWANZOO SOLUTION

Systematic Three-Month Testing of Apollo+Clay, Clay+Crawlers, and Offline Database

Methodical experimentation comparing three data sources over three months to identify optimal approach.

Contact Information Reliability Primary Challenge

Finding reliable contact information identified as the primary blocker for local business outreach success, not messaging.

Apollo + Clay Integration Testing

Tested database integration providing owners active on LinkedIn achieving 1% no-reply rate and 0.1% positive reply rate.

Data Source Uncertainty Across Providers

Multiple data sources available but unclear which would deliver best results for local business prospecting.

Clay + Website Crawlers Implementation

Tested website scraping generating 20,000+ leads but 50% missing emails and 40% invalid addresses. 1.1% no-reply, 0.4% positive.

Email Validity Issues Affecting Deliverability

High percentage of invalid email addresses across certain data sources limiting outreach effectiveness and campaign performance.

Offline Database Deployment

Tested specialized local business database achieving 1.7% no-reply rate and 1% positive reply rate. Most reliable source.

Response Rate Optimization Requirements

Need to maximize positive reply rates while minimizing wasted outreach to non-responsive contacts.

Comprehensive Data Collection Framework

Collected website domains, business owner emails, phone numbers, ratings, reviews, descriptions, news articles, LinkedIn URLs.

Kwanzoo's amazing website visitor identity solution can identify beyond company level data. I highly recommend checking it out.

Craig Booth

CSO & Partner, Sales Expert

SUCCESS FACTORS

Systematic Data Source Testing Framework Successfully Executed

Three-month testing provided definitive data on most reliable and cost-effective approach for local business outreach.

Offline Database Superior Performance Validated

Specialized local business database delivered 1.7% no-reply rate and 1% positive reply, outperforming alternatives on reliability.

Clay + Website Crawlers Scale Analysis

Generated 20,000+ leads cost-effectively but identified limitations with 50% missing emails and 40% invalid addresses.

Apollo + Clay Quality Assessment

Provided LinkedIn-active owners with 1% no-reply and 0.1% positive reply but limited by small sample size.

Comprehensive Cost-Benefit Analysis Completed

Offline Database $10K yearly for 10K leads monthly. Clay $450/month. Apollo $99/month. Instantly $97/month outreach platform.

GET IN TOUCH

Ready to Optimize Your Data Sources?

See how systematic testing can identify the most reliable contact data for your target market.